| Conference | Overall | ||||||
| GP | Record | Win % | GP | Record | Win % | ||
| Tusculum | 23 | 18-5 | 0.783 | 64 | 50-14 | 0.781 | |
| Carson-Newman | 21 | 15-6 | 0.714 | 56 | 36-20 | 0.643 | |
| Catawba | 22 | 12-10 | 0.545 | 51 | 32-19 | 0.627 | |
| Lenoir-Rhyne | 23 | 12-11 | 0.522 | 53 | 35-18 | 0.660 | |
| Newberry | 23 | 12-11 | 0.522 | 52 | 19-33 | 0.365 | |
| Wingate | 23 | 10-13 | 0.435 | 59 | 27-32 | 0.458 | |
| Lincoln Memorial | 20 | 7-13 | 0.350 | 51 | 31-20 | 0.608 | |
| Mars Hill | 21 | 7-14 | 0.333 | 52 | 21-31 | 0.404 | |
| Presbyterian | 24 | 7-17 | 0.292 | 54 | 18-36 | 0.333 | |